14 May PAPER 1 INSTRUCTIONS
Paper 1 Instructions
Due 11/17/2015
To be submitted through e-mail: cjgibilisco@gmail.com
1 General Instructions
Paper 2 will require you to present a philosophical argument and defend it from a criticism. That
is, youre going to present an argument you like, and then consider an objection against your
view. Then you write why you think that criticism fails.
• Goal: Write a paper in defense of a philosophical argument.
• Topics: You may write a paper defending any argument weve discussed in class other than
arguments about the existence of God. I give detailed instructions on two possible topics.
You can write on these topics if youre unsure what to write on, or use them as a guide if
you decide to write on another topic. For example, you may:
present and defend Principle of Alternative Possibilities as the correct view about
moral responsibility
or present and defend Frankfurts view that moral responsibility does not require the
ability to do otherwise
or write present and defend another view (modeling your papers structure on the
two example papers given below)
• If you choose to defend the Principle of Alternative Possibilities, Paper 2 will (roughly)
consist of the following parts:
1. Introduction: Explain the debate between compatibilists and incompatibilists (what
are the two dierent dentions of free choice?), dene key terms (especially the Principle
of Alternative Possibilities and other terms related to moral responsibility)
2. Thesis statement: thesis statements are like a road map for your reader: it tells your
reader where you plan on going and how you plan on getting there. In your thesis
statement, you will state the goal of your paper (give an argument and defend it from
a criticism), and how you will prove it.
“In this paper, I will argue that the principle of alternative possibilities is the
correct view of moral responsibility, because [list the reasons you think its true].
I also consider an objection to this argument, and argue that it fails.”
1
Paper 2 Instructions 2
3. Reconstruction: fully state van Inwagens argument for the principle alternative
possibilities (p. 254 of van Inwagen, and class notes)
4. Criticism: give the strongest criticism against the argument you can think of, either
using an argument from class or of your own making
The objection we considered in class was Frankfurts Smith and Jones case, which
apparently shows that someone can be morally responsible without having the
ability to do otherwise (pp. 8356 of Frankfurt, and class notes), making the
Principle of Alternative Possibilities false
5. Response to Criticism: Explain why that criticism fails. You may use an argument
from class or of your own making to respond to the criticism
6. Bibliography/Works Cited Page: You must fully cite every source that you use
for this paper
You may use a bibliography generator online, but double-check your entry against
the guidelines given on Purdues OWL page.
If you use the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, there are instructions for
citations here: plato.stanford.edu/cite.html
Here is the bibliographical information for Peter van Inwagen:
* Author: van Inwagen, Peter
* Book title: Metaphysics
* Edition: 3rd Edition
* Publisher: Westview
* City of Publication: Boulder, CO
* Year: 2009
Here is the bibliographical information for Frankfurt:
* Author: Frankfurt, Harry G.
* Article Title: Alternative Possibilities and Moral Responsibility
* Journal Title: Journal of Philosophy
* Volume: 66
* Issue: 23
* Year: 1969
* Pages: 829839
• If you choose to defend Frankfurts viewthat moral responsibility does not require
the ability to do otherwise, Paper 2 will (roughly) consist of the following parts:
1. Introduction: Explain the debate between compatibilists and incompatibilists (what
are the two dierent dentions of free choice? determinism? And so on), dene key
terms (especially the Principle of Alternative Possibilities and other terms related to
moral responsibility)
2. Thesis statement: thesis statements are like a road map for your reader: it tells your
reader where you plan on going and how you plan on getting there. In your thesis
Paper 2 Instructions 3
statement, you will state the goal of your paper (give an argument and defend it from
a criticism), and how you will prove it.
“In this paper, I will argue that Frankfurts compatibilist viewabout moral responsibility
is correct, because [list the reasons you think its true]. I also consider an
objection to this argument, and argue that it fails.”
3. Reconstruction: fully state Frankfurts Smith and Jones case, and explain why it
shows that moral responsibility is compatible with determinism (p. 8356 of Frankfurt,
class notes)
4. Criticism: give the strongest criticism against the argument you can think of, either
using an argument from class or of your own making
The objection we considered in class was Inwagens argument that moral responsibility
requires the existence of alternative possibilities (that is, that moral
responsibility is incompatible with determinism) (p. 254 of van Inwagen, and
class notes)
5. Response to Criticism: Explain why that criticism fails. You may use an argument
from class or of your own making to respond to the criticism
6. Bibliography/Works Cited Page: You must fully cite every source that you use
for this paper
You may use a bibliography generator online, but double-check your entry against
the guidelines given on Purdues OWL page.
If you use the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, there are instructions for
citations here: plato.stanford.edu/cite.html
Here is the bibliographical information for Peter van Inwagen:
* Author: van Inwagen, Peter
* Book title: Metaphysics
* Edition: 3rd Edition
* Publisher: Westview
* City of Publication: Boulder, CO
* Year: 2009
Here is the bibliographical information for Frankfurt:
* Author: Frankfurt, Harry G.
* Article Title: Alternative Possibilities and Moral Responsibility
* Journal Title: Journal of Philosophy
* Volume: 66
* Issue: 23
* Year: 1969
* Pages: 829839
Paper 2 Instructions 4
2 Grading
You will be graded on the following rubric:
• General
The paper has. . .
* has a clear and accurate thesis statement
* has proper citations
* has a bibliography/works cited page that properly cites every source the paper
uses
* is clearly written
* is accurate
• Comprehensiveness
The papers introduction. . .
* denes all key terms used in the paper
* has a clear and accurate thesis statement
The papers reconstruction. . .
* is clearly presented
* is accurate and fully reconstructed
* explains what the argument is meant to show about moral responsibility
The criticism of the paper is. . .
* is clearly presented
* actually applies to the view presented in the reconstruction
* is plausible
* is fully explained
The response to the criticism. . .
* is clearly presented
* actually applies to the criticism presented in the criticism
* is plausible
* fully explains why the objection fails
3 Plagiarism
You absolutely may not collaborate with classmates when it comes to writing this paper.
You may discuss this paper with classmates, research together, and share ideas1, but you
1If you use a classmates idea, you must credit them in a footnote: “I owe this idea to [insert his or her name here].”
If you use someone elses idea without crediting them, even a friend, that counts as plagiarism. Just remember to
give credit where credit is due.
Paper 2 Instructions 5
absolutely may not write any part of the paper together, or base your writing on a classmates.
Any sign of collaboration will be treated as plagiarism.
Our website has a team of professional writers who can help you write any of your homework. They will write your papers from scratch. We also have a team of editors just to make sure all papers are of HIGH QUALITY & PLAGIARISM FREE. To make an Order you only need to click Ask A Question and we will direct you to our Order Page at WriteDemy. Then fill Our Order Form with all your assignment instructions. Select your deadline and pay for your paper. You will get it few hours before your set deadline.
Fill in all the assignment paper details that are required in the order form with the standard information being the page count, deadline, academic level and type of paper. It is advisable to have this information at hand so that you can quickly fill in the necessary information needed in the form for the essay writer to be immediately assigned to your writing project. Make payment for the custom essay order to enable us to assign a suitable writer to your order. Payments are made through Paypal on a secured billing page. Finally, sit back and relax.
About Writedemy
We are a professional paper writing website. If you have searched a question and bumped into our website just know you are in the right place to get help in your coursework. We offer HIGH QUALITY & PLAGIARISM FREE Papers.
How It Works
To make an Order you only need to click on “Order Now” and we will direct you to our Order Page. Fill Our Order Form with all your assignment instructions. Select your deadline and pay for your paper. You will get it few hours before your set deadline.
Are there Discounts?
All new clients are eligible for 20% off in their first Order. Our payment method is safe and secure.